Tag
Featured Blog
blog image
November 19, 2024

Patterns of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Admissions During COVID-19: Key Insights from Clinical Data

A recent study from Istanbul sheds light on how psychiatric admissions and diagnoses changed during the first few months of the pandemic compared to previous periods, offering critical insights for parents, clinicians, and policymakers. 

This study, conducted by a team of researchers led by Ozalp Ekinci, examined psychiatric admissions among children and adolescents during 2019 and 2020. 

By looking at diagnosis rates for various psychiatric conditions, the researchers aimed to pinpoint shifts in the mental health landscape as a direct response to the pandemic.

Findings: A Closer Look at Diagnosis Patterns

The analysis revealed several notable trends in psychiatric diagnoses among children and adolescents:

  1. Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD): ASD diagnoses were notably higher in the early pandemic phase (6.4% in Group A) compared to the same period in the previous year (3.6%). This increase could reflect heightened stress or changes in routines that may have exacerbated underlying symptoms, leading to more frequent clinical presentations.
  2. Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD) and Tic Disorders: OCD and tic disorder diagnoses also saw a rise, increasing from 1.7% in 2019 to 2.9% during the pandemic’s onset. It’s possible that pandemic-driven anxieties and hygiene concerns, as well as disruptions to typical routines, may have worsened symptoms in those predisposed to OCD and similar disorders.
  3. Intellectual Disability (ID): Diagnoses for ID rose from 2.1% (Group C) to 3.7% (Group A). This increase highlights the challenges faced by children with developmental and intellectual disabilities, who may have experienced heightened difficulty adapting to the many changes imposed by the pandemic.
  4. Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): ADHD diagnoses were significantly higher in the pandemic phase (59.8% for Group A vs. 49.7% for Group B). With altered school structures, remote learning, and restricted socialization, ADHD symptoms could have been amplified, making it harder for children to concentrate and adhere to routines.
  5. Depression: Depression diagnoses also saw a rise (4.1% in Group A vs. 2.2% in Group C). Isolation, disruption of daily activities, and reduced social interactions likely contributed to increased depressive symptoms, particularly in adolescents who rely heavily on peer support.
  6. Conduct Disorder (CD): Interestingly, CD diagnoses were lower during the pandemic phase compared to pre-pandemic levels (3.6% in Group A vs. 6.4% in Group B). The reduction in face-to-face interactions and less exposure to traditional school settings may have lessened some of the typical triggers associated with conduct-related issues.
Implications

This study’s findings highlight some key takeaways that can guide mental health support efforts for children and adolescents:

  1. Increased Need for Early Support in Neurodevelopmental Disorders: The rise in ASD and ADHD diagnoses points to the need for specialized support in times of crisis, particularly for children who depend on routine and structure. Families and educators should work to create consistent environments that help manage symptoms.
  2. Addressing Pandemic-Induced Anxiety: With heightened cases of OCD and tic disorders, it’s clear that the pandemic’s emphasis on cleanliness and health may have intensified anxiety-driven behaviors. Future mental health responses should include strategies to manage health-related fears and equip children with coping skills.
  3. Supporting Emotional Resilience in Adolescents: Depression was notably higher among young people during the pandemic onset, suggesting a critical need for access to counseling and peer support, especially in times of isolation. Developing robust virtual mental health resources and promoting mental well-being in schools can help support children and adolescents both in and out of school.
  4. Recognizing the Complexity of Behavioral Changes: The drop in conduct disorder diagnoses during the pandemic suggests a link between behavioral disorders and social settings. Understanding these dynamics could lead to more tailored interventions that account for environmental factors impacting behavior.
Conclusion: 

As we continue to see the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on mental health, studies like this one serve as important reminders of the unique mental health needs of young people. Supporting children and adolescents through proactive and targeted mental health services—especially during times of crisis—will be crucial to fostering resilience and well-being in future generations.

No items found.
blog image

Interpreting Vehicular Accident Data in Relation To Those With ADHD

Nationwide population study finds high relative risk of traffic crashes among the elderly with ADHD, but with very low frequency, muddling interpretation of the results

Researchers from the Swedish Department of Global Public Health, the Swedish Transport Agency, and the Swedish National Road and Transport Research Institute collaborated in a nationwide population study of motor vehicle crashes among the elderly, defined as 65 and older.

They availed themselves of the country's all-encompassing national registers to identify the anonymized records of all such drivers from 2011 through 2016. That enabled them to compare crash records of those with known driving-impairing conditions with matched drivers who had no record of such conditions.

They looked only at road traffic crashes that resulted in injury to the driver or a passenger. For anyone with multiple crash records, they only looked at the first.

This was a case-control study, with two controls matched to each case wherever possible. For every case of a 65 or older driver involved in an injurious crash, the team randomly matched two individual controls by sex, birth year, municipality of residence, and other medical conditions. Place of residence was used to distinguish residents of large cities, who would tend to drive less frequently and in denser traffic, from those in small towns and rural areas. To minimize controls that never drive, only those with a driver's license and car were considered.

Of the thirteen medical conditions examined, elderly drivers with "ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, and similar conditions" had by far the highest odds of being in crashes that resulted in injury "at almost three times the rate of those without those conditions."

But note carefully the serious limitations in the data:

  • ADHD was bundled in with autism spectrum disorder and "similar conditions", making an unalloyed evaluation impossible.
  • Out of a total of 13,701 crashes, only 26 involved any of these conditions.
  • Because of the small number, the two-for-one matching broke down completely. Only 17 matched controls could be found, less than a third of the target of 52.
  • That means that despite a nationwide sample involving over 40,000 cases and controls, the sample size for "ADHD, autism spectrum disorder and similar conditions" was only 43.
The authors noted that while the high odds ratio "for ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, and similar conditions, are in line with previous studies on young adult drivers and adult drivers in this recent cohort of older, Swedish adults, such conditions are very uncommon compared to younger adults, suggesting likely under-diagnosis. Hence, the results should be interpreted with caution."
September 26, 2023
blog image

Connection Found Between Air Pollution and ADHD

Large longitudinal cohort study finds association between nitric oxide in air pollution and ADHD (hyperactivity)

Strong association found between gestational exposure to high levels of nitrogen oxide and later ADHD-hyperactive symptoms.

Taiwan's National Birth Registration database tracks every birth. Using all entries from 2005, random sampling was used to create the Taiwan Birth Cohort Study of 24,200 mother-infant pairs, which were geographically distributed and represented 12 percent of all births.

As this was an eight-year longitudinal study, there were dropouts, and 17,256 pairs completed the study. After excluding cases with fetal distress, smoking or alcohol use during pregnancy, and missing information on covariates, the final study population was 16,376.

Participants' addresses during gestation were geocoded to the township level, and local air pollution data was retrieved for the years 2004 to 2006 from air quality monitoring stations administered by Taiwan's Environmental Protection Administration. Every hour, each station records levels of nitric oxide (NO), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), sulfur dioxide (SO2), carbon monoxide (CO), and particulate matter of diameter 10 μm or less (PM10).

The Taiwanese research team addressed several potential confounding factors: sex, maternal age, delivery method (cesarean section or not), birth in summer (June-August), urban or rural residence, and annual household income.

Because ADHD is primarily observable as hyperactivity rather than inattention among young children, the team focused on relating symptoms of hyperactivity to levels of air pollutants.

After adjusting for covariates, the team found no significant association between PM10 and SO2 levels and hyperactivity disorder. Nitrogen oxide levels, on the other hand, were associated with more than 25 percent higher odds of hyperactivity.

Breaking that down further, they found no significant association with NO2, and that the 25 percent higher odds were exclusive with nitric oxide (NO), a pollutant emitted by internal combustion engines in cars, trucks, and busses. NO is a free radical, meaning it has an unpaired electron that can damage the body because of its strong chemical reactivity.

The authors noted, "Our study has some limitations. First, hyperactivity was diagnosed based on a parent-reported physician or specialist diagnosis. Although we did not inquire which specialists made these diagnoses, they must have been a pediatrician, psychiatrist, or special education teacher. ... Second, the calculated exposure to ambient air pollutants was not an accurate personal exposure because it did not take indoor air pollutant levels and time-activity patterns into consideration. Applying personal environmental monitoring in such a large sample is impractical, especially when the subjects are pregnant."

Nevertheless, they emphasized, "this is the first study attempting to discover which component of NOx is more critical to the development of hyperactivity in offspring."

January 20, 2022
blog image

Reconsidering the Age-of-Onset Criterion in Older Adults Being Evaluated for ADHD

Reconsidering the Age-of-Onset Criterion in Older Adults Being Evaluated for ADHD

The current Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5) requires evidence of symptom onset before age 12 to make a diagnosis of ADHD in adults.

A recently published clinical review questions the appropriateness of this criterion in older adults 50 years old and above. It sets forth several reasons:

  • ADHD was first recognized in the DSM in 1968, just over fifty years ago. Anyone over fifty is highly unlikely to have been diagnosed with ADHD in childhood, or even to have symptoms properly noticed.
  • It is well-established that memories both fade and change with time. Even among young adults, only about half can recall the age at which specific memories occurred. For older adults, the challenge is much greater, and that means questionnaire answers become unreliable.
  • Episodic memory among persons with ADHD is known to be impaired relative to controls, which further limits the reliability of memory, especially over extended periods.

On the other hand, the reason for the early onset criterion is to avoid any confusion with early neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's or Lewy body dementia, which have overlapping symptoms.

The authors suggest a possible fix:

  • For those over fifty, readjust the under-12 criterion to instead demonstrate the longstanding previous existence of ADHD symptoms, without forcing it to include the first eleven years of life. They call for research to determine how many years of previous symptoms would best distinguish ADHD symptoms from normal aging and the onset of dementia.
  • Establish a family history of ADHD. Heritability estimates suggest that ADHD occurs in roughly half the parents of people with ADHD, and about 15% of grandparents. That means that for persons over 50, having children and/or grandchildren with ADHD would lend greater weight to self-reported ADHD symptoms.
  • Noting that "cognitive functioning rating scales(e.g., the Barkley Deficits in Executive Functioning Scale) have shown to align robustly with ADHD symptoms," they "call for studies investigating the use of these rating scales in older adult samples, and particularly their discriminant validity relative to other late-life disorders affecting cognition."
  • This would be accompanied by careful screening for physical or psychiatric comorbidities, to reduce the risk of false positives.

It is unethical, the authors suggest, to deny care to older, presently undiagnosed adults, given the demonstrated poor outcomes associated with untreated ADHD.

January 16, 2022
blog image

Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation and Improving Response Inhibition

How effective is transcranial direct current stimulation at improving response inhibition?

Though initially offering some measurable results, further high-quality studies are needed to determine how effective tDCS may be in treating certain ADHD symptoms.

Inhibitory control is an essential cognitive control function whereby the prefrontal cortex blocks planned motor actions or interrupts motor actions already initiated by other parts of the brain. For example, someone might instinctually reach for a candy bar but then put it back upon thinking that eating it would conflict with a higher-level goal of cutting down on sugar consumption. Impairment of inhibitory control is a known characteristic of several psychiatric disorders, including ADHD.

Any generally safe treatment with the ability to at least partially reverse such impairment would therefore be useful. Researchers are currently experimenting with transcranial direct current stimulation, a non-invasive brain stimulation technique that uses a weak electrical current to stimulate specific regions of the brain.

What, then, do we know so far about its potential effectiveness for improving inhibitory control?

A team of experts at the University of Tübingen in Germany conducted a comprehensive search of the peer-reviewed medical literature to find out. They then performed a meta-analysis of 45 studies with a combined total of over 1,600 participants. All but four of the studies used sham or other active controls.

The overall meta-analysis found a significant but small improvement in response inhibition. But it also found evidence of publication bias. Adjusting for publication bias reduced the effect size in half, to a tiny but still significant improvement.

The meta-analysis relied on two behavioral tasks that require inhibitory control to measure response inhibition: the go-/no-task, and the stop-signal task. Separating these, there was no significant improvement in the go/no-go task performance. All the improvement was concentrated on the stop-signal task.

The authors noted, "A potential limitation of this meta-analysis is that we could not exhaustively model-dependent relationships between moderator variables (e.g., tDCS polarity and electrode placement)," and "Further high-quality studies are needed to investigate potential interactions between technical and functional parameters in tDCS research."

January 14, 2022
blog image

The Use of EEGs in Diagnosing Various Levels of Adult ADHD

Adult ADHD: How do those with the full syndrome compare with those who are subthreshold on executive functioning, and are EEGs of any use in diagnosis?

German researchers study how useful EEG markers may or may not be in the treatment of full-spectrum ADHD as compared to sub-threshold ADHD.

Noting that to date, no study investigated potential behavioral and neural markers in adults with subthreshold ADHD as compared to adults with full syndrome ADHD and healthy controls, the German team of researchers at the University of Tübingen out to do just that, recruiting volunteers through flyers and advertisements.

Their ADHD sample consisted of 113 adults between 18 and 60 years of age (mean age 38) who fulfilled the DSM-IV-TR criteria of ADHD and were either not on medication or a steady dose of medication over the prior two months.

Another 46 participants (also mean age 38), whose symptoms did not reach the DSM-IV-TR criteria, were assigned to the group with subthreshold ADHD.

The control sample was comprised of 42 healthy participants (mean age 37).

Individuals with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, borderline personality disorder, epilepsy, or traumatic brain injury were excluded from the sample, as were those with current substance abuse or dependence.

All participants were German-speaking Caucasians. There were no significant differences in gender, age, education, or verbal/nonverbal intelligence among the three groups.

Participants first completed an online pre-screening, which was followed up with an interview to confirm the ADHD diagnosis.

ADHD impairs executive functions, "defined as the 'top-down' cognitive abilities for maintaining problem-solving skills to achieve future goals." The researchers explored three categories of executive functioning: 1) capacity for inhibition, "the ability to inhibit dominant, automatic, or prepotent responses when necessary- 2) ability to shift, enabling smooth switching between tasks or mental sets; and 3) ability to update, "updating and monitoring of working memory representations." Participants took a battery of neuropsychological tests to assess performance in each category.

Significant differences emerged between the group with ADHD and healthy controls in all measures except one: the STROOP Reading test. But there were no significant differences between participants suffering from subthreshold and full-syndrome ADHD. Nor were there any significant differences between those with subthreshold ADHD and healthy controls.

The researchers also recorded electroencephalograms(EEGs) for each participant. In healthy individuals, there is little to no association between resting-state EEG spectral power measures and executive functions. In individuals with ADHD, some studies have indicated increased theta-to-beta ratios, while others have found no significant differences. This study found no significant differences between the three groups.

The authors concluded, "The main results of the study can be summarized as follows: First, increased executive function deficits (in updating, inhibition, and shifting functions) could be observed in the full syndrome ADHD as compared to the healthy control group while, on the electrophysiological level, no differences in the theta to the beta ratio between these groups were found. Second, we observed only slightly impaired neuropsychological functions and no abnormal electrophysiological activity in the subthreshold ADHD sample. Taken together, our data suggest some practical uses of the assessment of objective cognitive markers but no additional value of examining electrophysiological characteristics in the diagnosis of subthreshold and full syndrome ADHD in adulthood."

They added, "These findings deeply question the value of including resting EEG markers into the diagnostic procedure and also have implications for standard neurofeedback protocols frequently used in the treatment of ADHD, where patients are trained to reduce their theta power while simultaneously increasing beta activity."

January 12, 2022
blog image

Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation: Can It Treat ADHD?

How effective and safe is transcranial direct current stimulation for treating ADHD?

ADHD is hypothesized to arise from 1) poor inhibitory control resulting from impaired executive functions which are associated with reduced activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and increased activation of some subcortical regions; and 2)hyperarousal to environmental stimuli, hampering the ability of the executive functioning system, particularly the medial frontal cortex, orbital and ventromedial prefrontal areas, and subcortical regions such as the caudate nucleus, amygdala, nucleus accumbens, and thalamus, to control the respective stimuli.

These brain anomalies, rendered visible through magnetic resonance imaging, have led researchers to try new means of treatment to directly address the deficits. Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) is a non-invasive brain stimulation technique that uses a weak electrical current to stimulate specific regions of the brain.

Efficacy:

A team of researchers from Europe and ran performed a systematic search of the literature and identified fourteen studies exploring the safety and efficacy of tDCS. Three of these studies examined the effects on ADHD symptoms. They found a large effect size for the inattention subscale and a medium effect size for the hyperactivity/impulsivity. Yet, as the authors cautioned, "a definite conclusion concerning the clinical efficacy of tDCS based on the results of these three studies is not possible."

The remaining studies investigated the effects on specific neuropsychological and cognitive deficits in ADHD:

  •  Working memory was improved by anodal stimulation - but not cathodal stimulation - of the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Anodal stimulation of the right inferior frontal gyrus had no effect.
  •  Response inhibition: Anodal stimulation of the left or right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex was more effective than anodal stimulation of the bilateral prefrontal cortex.
  • Motivational and emotional processing was improved only with stimulation of both the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and orbitofrontal cortex.

The fact that heterogeneity in the methodology of these studies made meta-analysis impossible means these results, while promising, cannot be seen as in any way definitive.

Safety:

Ten studies examined childhood ADHD. Three found no adverse effects either during or after tDCS. One study reported a feeling of "shock" in a few patients during tDCS. Several more reported skin tingling and itching during tDCS. Several also reported mild headaches.

The four studies of adults with ADHD reported no major adverse events. One study reported a single incident of acute mood change, sadness, diminished motivation, and tension five hours after stimulation. Another reported mild instances of skin tingling and burning sensations.

To address side effects such as tingling and itching, the authors suggested reducing the intensity of the electrical current and increasing the duration. They also suggested placing electrodes at least 6 cm apart to reduce current shunting through the ski. For children, they recommended the use of smaller electrodes for better focus in smaller brains.

The authors concluded, "The findings of this systematic review suggest at least a partial improvement of symptoms and cognitive deficits in ADHD by tDCS. They further suggest that stimulation parameters such as polarity and site are relevant to the efficacy of tDCS in ADHD. Compared to cathodal stimulation, Anodal tDCS seems to have a superior effect on both the clinical symptoms and cognitive deficits. However, the routine clinical application of this method as an efficient therapeutic intervention cannot yet be recommended based on these studies ..."

January 10, 2022
blog image

Is There Any Hard Evidence in Support of Homeopathic Remedies for ADHD?

Is there any hard evidence in support of homeopathic remedies for ADHD?

According to Vox, "Homeopathy is a $1.2 billion industry in the US alone, used by an estimated 5 million adults and 1 million kids. It's become such a staple of America's wellness industry that leading brands such as Boiron and Hyland's are readily available at high-end health-focused chains like Whole Foods and sprouts, supermarkets like Ralph's, and superstores such as Walmart."

Yet, this highly profitable "wellness" industry has shown little to no interest in supporting randomized clinical trials (RCTs) to test the efficacy and safety of its products.

In a team of Italian physicians, Rana comprehensive search of the medical literature and found only nine RCTs exploring the efficacy and safety of homeopathic remedies for psychiatric disorders that met the selection criteria.

Only two of these RCTs addressed efficacy for ADHD, with a combined 99 participants. Neither reported any significant effect.

Combining them into a small meta-analysis likewise found no significant effect.

But that's not all. According to the study authors, "The paucity of published trials does not allow a reliable estimate of publication bias, which would require a larger number of studies. This is a major issue since it has been reported that, among completed trials of homeopathy registered on ClinicalTrials.gov, only 46% were published within 2 years of completion, and among these, 25% altered or changed their primary outcomes. It is, therefore, possible that the results of the present meta-analysis are distorted because of selective publication."

The authors conclude, "The most surprising result of this meta-analysis is the paucity of available data from RCTs," and "Based on the very few available trials, homeopathy did not produce any relevant effect on symptoms of ADHD ... Ethical considerations should therefore prevent clinicians from recommending HRs [homeopathic remedies], which have a cost either for patients or for health care systems, until when a sufficient amount of solid evidence becomes available."

January 8, 2022
blog image

Population Study Finds Association Between ADHD and Obesity in Adolescents

Israeli nationwide population study finds association between ADHD and obesity in adolescents

After noting that the association between ADHD and obesity has been called into question because of small sample sizes, wide age ranges, self-reported assessments, and inadequate attention to potential confounders, an Israeli study team set out "to assess the association between board-certified psychiatrist diagnoses of ADHD and measured adolescent BMI [body mass index] in a nationally represented sample of over one million adolescents who were medically evaluated before mandatory military service."

The team distinguished between severe and mild ADHD. It also focused on a single age group.

All Israelis are subject to compulsory military service. In preparation for that service, military physicians perform a thorough medical evaluation. Trained paramedics recorded every conscript's height and weight.

The study cohort was divided into five BMI percentile groups according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's BMI percentiles for 17-year-olds, and further divided by sex: <5th percentile (underweight), 5th-49th percentile (low-normal), 50th-84th percentile (high normal), 85th-94th percentile (overweight) and ≥95th (obese). Low-normal was used as the reference group.

Adjustments were made for sex, birth year, age at examination, height, country of birth (Israeli or other), socioeconomic status, and education level.

In the fully adjusted results, those with severe ADHD were 32% more likely to be overweight and 84% more likely to be obese than their typically developing peers. Limiting results to Israeli-born conscripts made a no difference.

Male adolescents with mild ADHD were 24% more likely to be overweight, and 42% more likely to be obese. Females with mild ADHD are 33% more likely to be overweight, and 42% more likely to be obese. Again, the country of birth made no difference.

The authors concluded, that both severe and mild ADHD was associated with an increased risk for obesity in adolescents at the age of 17 years. The increasing recognition of the persistence of ADHD into adulthood suggests that this dual morbidity may have a significant impact on the long-term health of individuals with ADHD, thus early preventive measures should be taken.

January 6, 2022
blog image

Taiwan population study finds association between ADHD and adrenal gland dysfunction

Taiwan population study finds association between ADHD and adrenal gland dysfunction

Youths with ADHD were found to be 2.4 times more likely than their peers to have adrenal gland abnormalities.

Cortisol is a steroid hormone produced by the adrenal glands situated above the kidneys. Its release is boosted by low blood sugar, which it counteracts, and also in response to stress.

Previous studies on children with ADHD have pointed to lower basal cortisol concentrations in the morning and a significantly lower incidence of typical diurnal fluctuation in cortisol levels.

To better assess the comorbidity of ADHD and adrenal gland disorders, a Taiwan research team affiliated with Chang Gung University College of Medicine used the National Health Insurance database to conduct a nationwide population study. Taiwan has a single-payer national health insurance system that encompasses almost the entire population, and its extensive database facilitates such studies.

Looking at the thirteen years from 1999 through 2011, the team identified 75,247 youths (manage ten years) newly diagnosed with ADHD and matched them by age and sex to another 75, 247 youths not diagnosed with ADHD.

To guard against confounding variables, they also identified psychiatric conditions that are comorbid with ADHD, including oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder, autism spectrum disorder, tic disorder, and intellectual disability.

After adjusting for age, sex, and psychiatric comorbidities, youths with ADHD were still 2.4 times more likely to have adrenal gland abnormalities than their normally developing peers. To place this in context, adrenal gland dysfunctions are very uncommon, in this instance occurring in roughly one in a thousand controls, and two in a thousand youths with ADHD.

The team also explored whether the two ADHD medications approved for use in Taiwan had any effect on the outcome. Methylphenidate, a stimulant, is the preferred treatment, with atomoxetine, a non-stimulant, used as an alternative where methylphenidate is inadvisable or found to be suboptimal. Neither methylphenidate nor atomoxetine had any significant effect on the risk of adrenal gland dysfunction.

The authors concluded, "Patients with ADHD had greater comorbid rates with adrenal gland dysfunction than the control subjects. Nevertheless, receiving pharmacotherapy (MPH or ATX) did not significantly influence the risk of developing adrenal gland dysfunction among ADHD patients. Therefore, continuous efforts are needed to promote public awareness of potential adrenal gland dysfunction among ADHD patients."

January 4, 2022
blog image

How Effective is Cognitive Training for Preschool Children?

How effective is cognitive training for preschool children?

Further study is needed, but meta-analysis shows small, but not insignificant, effects of pre-school interventions on core executive functions.

A German team of researchers performed a comprehensive search of the medical literature and identified 35randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published in English that explored this question. Participating children were between three and six years old. Children with intellectual disabilities, sensory disabilities, or specific neurological disorders such as epilepsy were excluded.

The total number of participating preschoolers was over three thousand, drawn almost exclusively from the general population, meaning these studies were not specifically evaluating effects on children with ADHD. But given that ADHD results in poorer executive functioning, evidence of the effectiveness of cognitive training would suggest it could help partially reverse such deficits.

RCTs assign participants randomly to a treatment group and a group not receiving treatment but often receiving a placebo. But RCTs themselves vary in risk of bias, depending on:

  • whether the control condition was passive (i.e. waiting list or no treatment) or active/sham (an activity of similar duration and intensity to the treatment condition)
  • whether the outcome was measured by subjective rating (e.g. by questionnaires, susceptible to reporting biases) or more objective neuropsychological testing;
  • whether the assessment of outcome was by blinded assessors unaware of participants' treatment conditions;
  • whether there was a risk of bias from participants dropping out of the trial.

After evaluating the RCTs by these criteria, the team performed a series of meta-analyses.

Combining the 23 RCTs with over 2,000 children that measured working memory, they found that cognitive training led to robust moderate improvements. Looking only at the eleven most rigorously controlled studies strengthened the effect, with moderate-to-large gains.

Twenty-six RCTs with over 2,200 children assessed inhibitory control. When pooled, they indicated a small-to-moderate improvement from cognitive training. Including only the seven most rigorously controlled studies again strengthened the effect, boosting it into the moderate effect zone.

Twelve RCTs with over 1,500 participants tested the effects of cognitive training on flexibility. When combined, they pointed to moderate gains. Looking at only the four well-controlled studies boosted the effect to strong gains. Yet here there was evidence of publication bias, so no firm conclusion can be drawn.

Only four studies with a combined total of 119 preschoolers tested the effects on ADHD ratings. The meta-analysis found a small but non-significant improvement, very likely due to insufficient sampling. As the authors noted, "some findings of the meta-analysis are limited by the insufficient number of eligible studies. Specifically, more studies are needed which use blinded assessments of subjective ratings of ADHD ... symptoms ..."

The authors concluded that their meta-analyses revealed significant, mostly medium-sized effects of the preschool interventions on core EFs [executive functions] in studies showing the low risk of bias."

January 2, 2022
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.