October 25, 2023

Meta-analysis claims effectiveness of multi-nutrient supplements in treating ADHD, but reports inconsistent results and has methodological shortcomings

A recently published meta-analysis compared the treatment of ADHD with multi-nutrient supplements versus placebo.

Children received either placebo or Daily Essential Nutrients(Vit A 384 IU, Vit C 40 mg, Vit D 200 IU, Vit E 24 IU, Vit K 8 μg, B1 4 mg, B21.2 mg, B3 6 mg, B6 4.67 mg, B9 50 μg, B12 60 μg, B7 72 μg, B5 2 mg, Ca 88 mg, Fe 0.92 mg, P 56 mg, I 13.6 μg, Mg 40 mg, Zn 3.2 mg, Se 13.6 μg, Cu 0.48 mg, Mn0.64 mg, Cr 41.6 μg, Mo 9.6 μg, P 16 mg. Proprietary blend: Choline bitartrate, Alpha-lipoic acid, Inositol, Acety-l-carnitine (as acetyl-L-carnitine hydrochloride), Grape seed extract, Ginkgo biloba leaf extract, Methionine (asL-methionine hydrochloride), Cysteine (as N-acetyl-L-cysteine), Germanium sesquioxide (as chelate), Boron, Vanadium, Lithium orotate, Nickel. Other ingredients: Cellulose glycine 45 mg, Citric acid 26.814 mg, Magnesium stearate24 mg, Silicon dioxide 20 mg).

Adults received either placebo or EMP+ (Vit A 5760IU, Vit C 600 mg, Vit D 1440 IU, Vit E 360 IU, B1 18 mg, B2 13.5 mg, B3 90 mg,B5 21.6 mg, B6 36 mg, B9 1440 μg, B12 900 μg, Biotin 1080 μg, Pantothenic acid21.6 mg, Ca 1320 mg, Fe 13.74 mg, P 840mg, I 204 μg, Mg 600 mg, Zn 48 mg, Se204 μg, Cu 7.2 mg, Mn 9.6 mg, Cr 624 μg, Mo 144 μg, K 240 mg, Germaniumsesquioxide 20.7 mg, B 2400 μg, V 1194 μg, Ni 29.4 μg, Choline bitartrate 540mg, DL-phenylalanine 360 mg, Citrus bioflavonoids 240 mg, Inositol 180 mg,Glutamine 180 mg, L-methionine 60 mg, Gingko biloba 36 mg, grape seed extract45 mg).

Using the Global Assessment of Functioning (GAF) scale for adults, and the Children's Global Assessment Scale (CGAS) for children, the study team reported moderate improvements in overall functioning from the use of the supplements. GAF and CGAF are used by mental health clinicians and physicians to rate subjectively the social, occupational, and psychological functioning of an individual.

Yet no significant improvements were found for either clinician-rated or observer-rated ADHD Change Scores.

Moreover, the positive finding was compromised by a series of methodological shortcomings:

·        It was just barely a meta-analysis, involving only two studies.
·        The combined number of participants in the two studies was small, 173, consisting of 93 children in one study and 80 adults in the other.
·        Both studies had the same lead author, Julia J. Rucklidge, who was also a member of the meta-analysis team.

With only two studies, there was no way to evaluate publication bias.

Jeanette M. Johnstone, Andrew Hughes, Joshua Z. Goldenberg, Amy R. Romijn, and Julia J. Rucklidge, "Multinutrients for the Treatment of Psychiatric Symptoms in Clinical Samples: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials," Nutrients (2020) 12, 3394, https://doi:10.3390/nu12113394.

Related posts

No items found.

Swedish Nationwide Population Study: Little ADHD Risk from Vacuum-Assisted Delivery

Vacuum-assisted delivery (VAD), also called vacuum extraction, is an assisted vaginal birth method in which a soft plastic cup is attached to the baby’s head with suction to help guide the infant through the birth canal during the pushing stage. Clinicians typically use VAD when labor stalls, the mother is exhausted, or there are concerns about the baby’s heart rate. It is an alternative to a cesarean section (C‑section) that can avoid major surgery. 

In Sweden, VAD is used in about 6%–9% of births, while forceps deliveries are uncommon. When performed with the fetal head at the outlet station (very low in the birth canal), VAD is usually quick and carries minimal risk of injury in full-term babies; these outlet procedures make up roughly half of all VADs. By contrast, several studies have linked VAD performed at mid or low fetal head stations with more serious neonatal complications, such as intracranial bleeding, seizures and, in rare cases, death. 

Despite concerns about short-term neonatal injury after mid/low VAD, research on long-term neurodevelopmental outcomes is limited. A few more recent studies have not found clear links between VAD and adverse long-term outcomes, but most of those studies did not separate outlet from mid/low procedures. 

To address this gap, the authors conducted a nationwide, population-based study in Sweden to compare neonatal and long-term neurodevelopmental outcomes after VAD, and to stratify results by fetal station. They included emergency cesarean delivery and spontaneous vaginal delivery as reference groups to help interpret outcomes after VAD. 

The study used Sweden’s linked national registers, possible because every resident has a personal identification number. Sweden’s tax-funded single-payer health system and nearly universal hospital births mean the registers provide comprehensive, standardized data suitable for long-term follow-up. 

The cohort comprised 630,985 singleton term births from 1997 through 2014. Of these, 73,215 (11.6%) were delivered by VAD, 73,739 (11.7%) by emergency cesarean delivery, and 484,031 (76.7%) by spontaneous vaginal delivery. Among the VAD births, 31,014 (42.4%) were classified as mid/low station and 42,201 (57.6%) as outlet VAD. 

The investigators adjusted their analyses for potential confounders including maternal age; early-pregnancy body-mass index; smoking during pregnancy; the child’s birth year; preeclampsia; gestational diabetes; chorioamnionitis; maternal education level; and maternal medical or psychiatric conditions (type 1 or type 2 diabetes, ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, depression and anxiety). 

After adjustment, VAD overall was associated with a 6% lower risk of later being diagnosed with ADHD compared with the reference groups. When broken down by fetal station, mid/low VAD showed no difference in ADHD risk, while outlet VAD was associated with a 9% lower risk. For comparison, spontaneous vaginal delivery was associated with a 12% lower risk of later ADHD. 

The authors concluded that, in this large nationwide cohort, the findings may offer reassuring evidence about the overall long-term neurodevelopmental safety of VAD.  

‍

‍

‍

Meta-analysis: Almost Three in Four ADHD Patients Receive Pharmaceutical Treatment

The Background:

Management of ADHD relies on both medications and non-medication approaches. Clinical guidelines often recommend medication as the first-line treatment for adults, while non-medication interventions are often preferred for children. Medicines fall into two main groups: stimulants (for example, methylphenidate and amphetamines), which have strong and well-established evidence and are generally considered first choice, and non-stimulants (such as atomoxetine), which are typically used when stimulants are contraindicated, not tolerated, or ineffective. 

How many people with ADHD receive medication is an important indicator of care quality and can be tracked at the national level. Untreated ADHD can affect many areas of life, from physical health, to school and work performance, to relationships emotional well-being. ADHD is associated with poorer quality of life, higher risk of accidents, substance use issues, criminal behavior, educational underachievement, and even increased premature mortality. The condition also places a substantial burden on families and caregivers, so understanding treatment rates matters for individuals and society. 

Most epidemiological research has measured how common diagnosed ADHD is, but the share of those diagnosed who actually receive medication can vary a lot. That variation reflects differences in how ADHD is diagnosed, how easy it is to get treatment, what clinical guidelines recommend, and cultural attitudes toward using medication. 

The Study:

This paper presents the first comprehensive meta-analysis to estimate how common pharmacological treatment is among children, adolescents, and adults with clinically confirmed ADHD. The analysis included only register-based population studies where diagnoses were confirmed by a qualified healthcare professional. Twelve studies meeting these criteria from Europe (the UK, Sweden, Denmark), Asia (Taiwan, South Korea), and North America (Canada, the United States) were used. Notably, these are all high-income areas, and thus unrepresentative of populations in lower-income countries.  

The pooled estimate showed that about 73 percent of diagnosed individuals in prosperous parts of the world with well-developed health care systems were receiving medication, but there was very high variation between studies. 

The Results:

The authors conclude there is substantial global variation in ADHD medication use. Overall, a relatively high proportion of people diagnosed with ADHD are treated with medication, which may reflect improved recognition and access to care. The large differences between studies probably reflect differing health systems, diagnostic rules, treatment definitions, study populations, and reporting practices, and they underline the need for more standardized definitions and reporting to make comparisons more meaningful.  

There is also a need for information from lower-income regions, but that is complicated by an absence of register-based population studies in countries with more limited health care access.

‍

November 4, 2026

Meta-analysis Finds Three- to Eight-fold Higher ADHD Prevalence Among Adults with Substance Use Disorders

The Background:

Because impulsivity is a core feature of ADHD, researchers have suggested it may raise the likelihood that someone will use psychoactive substances (including alcohol) and go on to develop a substance use disorder (SUD). When ADHD and SUD occur together in adolescents, treating one disorder alone usually has little or no positive effect on the other; current guidance therefore recommends treating both conditions at the same time using evidence-based approaches for each. 

Given how much ADHD can worsen outcomes for people with primary SUDs, it is important to identify ADHD in people who are being treated for substance problems. 

The Study:

A recent systematic meta-review found that, by current official criteria, ADHD affects about 7.2% of children and adolescents and about 2.6% of adults (Chaulagain et al., 2023). When adult ADHD is defined without the requirement that symptoms began by age 11, roughly 6.8% of adults meet criteria. A large body of research links ADHD to higher rates of medical problems, poorer quality of life, greater risk of suicide, more accidental injuries, worse educational outcomes, and increased involvement with the criminal justice system. 

The present study is the first meta-analysis to estimate how common clinically diagnosed ADHD is among adults (age 18+) who are in treatment for psychoactive substance use disorders, and to provide those estimates by sex and by the specific substance used. 

The authors included only studies of adults treated for a SUD (including alcohol). Eighty-four studies met the criteria, representing more than 34,000 people. Across all studies, the pooled prevalence of clinically diagnosed ADHD was 22%. 

To put that in context, 22% is about eight times higher than the 2.6% adult prevalence using the stricter official definition, and about three times higher than the 6.8% rate when the childhood-onset requirement is relaxed. By substance, the prevalence was similar for alcohol (24%) and opioids (22%), with no significant difference between males and females. Prevalence among people treated for cocaine use was somewhat lower overall (18%), driven largely by lower rates among women, for whom the rate was no higher than in the general population. Estimates were higher for people using benzodiazepines and cannabis, but those figures are based on a very small number of users (256 and 249 people, respectively) and are therefore less certain. 

The Results: 

The authors conclude: “These findings underscore the need for early identification and treatment of ADHD as most substance use disorders develop in adolescence and young adulthood. While in treatment for ADHD, appropriate screening and management of substance use is possible.” 

‍

October 29, 2026